PoliticalTests
Portrait of Henry David Thoreau
1817-1862United States

Portrait: B. D. Maxham, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Henry David Thoreau

Essayist and naturalist · Author of Walden and Civil Disobedience · Abolitionist and tax resister

Transcendentalist writer who refused to pay taxes to a government that waged the Mexican War and protected slavery, and whose Civil Disobedience became a manual for nonviolent resistance.

ECONOMYSTATE AND LIBERTYSOCIETYWORLDOwnershipMarketsWelfareAuthoritySecurityStructureMoralityReligionTechnologyCultureTradeForeign
  • Position
  • Solid, past the ring: second pole
  • Short, inside the ring: first pole
  • Balanced

★ Henry David Thoreau on 12 axes

Share of each pole

Economy

Equality / Markets
  • OwnershipNo clear record
    PublicPrivate
  • MarketsMild: Planned
    PlannedFree
  • WelfareModerate: Self-reliant
    SharedSelf-reliant

State and liberty

Liberty / Authority
  • AuthorityStrong: Democratic
    DemocraticStrong leader
  • SecurityStrong: Liberty
    LibertyOrder
  • StructureModerate: Local
    LocalCentral

Society

Progress / Tradition
  • MoralityNo clear record
    ProgressiveTraditional
  • ReligionMild: Secular
    SecularReligious
  • TechnologyModerate: Caution
    EmbraceCaution
  • CultureMild: Multicultural
    MulticulturalNational identity

World

Global / Nation
  • TradeNo clear record
    GlobalProtected
  • Foreign policyModerate: Cooperation
    CooperationStrength

How we placed it

Judgment calls

Positions summarize typical stances from primary sources and reference works. Where an axis is genuinely contested, the reasoning is below.

Markets
Ambivalent about capitalism: he admired the reach of commerce but criticized the factory system and speculation; scored near the center.
Welfare
Scored toward self-reliance for the simple, self-sufficient living he described in Walden, not for any stated welfare policy.
Structure
Distrusted the state and placed individual conscience above it, though he asked for a better government rather than none.
Morality
An ascetic nonconformist who rejected social consensus as proof of right; neither traditional nor progressive fits, so left null.
Religion
A transcendentalist who saw nature as sacred, he refused a tax to support a clergyman and objected to the state collecting it for the church.

3 axes are marked as no clear record: there is no reasonable basis to place Henry David Thoreau there, so matching leaves them out.

Who was Henry David Thoreau?

Henry David Thoreau was born in Concord, Massachusetts, in 1817 and attended Harvard College from 1833 to 1837. A friend and protege of Ralph Waldo Emerson, he lived from 1845 to 1847 in a small house he built near Walden Pond, the experience behind Walden (1854). In 1846 he spent a night in jail for refusing to pay his poll tax in protest against slavery and the Mexican-American War, and in 1849 he published the essay now known as Civil Disobedience. He wrote against the Fugitive Slave Law, defended John Brown after the raid on Harpers Ferry and died of tuberculosis in 1862.

Political views

  • Argued that individuals must follow conscience over unjust laws and should break such laws rather than wait for majorities to change them.

    Source: plato.stanford.edu
  • Refused to pay his poll tax for six years and was jailed for a night, protesting slavery and the Mexican-American War.

    Source: en.wikipedia.org
  • Rejected the no-government men, asking not at once for no government but at once for a better government.

    Source: gutenberg.org
  • Took part in the Underground Railroad, protested the Fugitive Slave Law and defended John Brown as justified.

    Source: plato.stanford.edu
  • Criticized consumerism, speculation and technology applied without purpose, urging a simpler life.

    Source: plato.stanford.edu
  • Campaigned for protecting animals and the natural environment, and is seen as an early advocate of preserving wilderness as public land.

    Source: en.wikipedia.org
  • Spoke out against the subjugation of Native Americans.

    Source: plato.stanford.edu

Legacy

Thoreau's Civil Disobedience influenced Leo Tolstoy, Mahatma Gandhi and Martin Luther King Jr., and his nature writing is often credited with anticipating ecology and the conservation movement. Admirers across the political spectrum, from libertarians to environmentalists and pacifists, claim him as a forerunner. Critics have called his stance on conscience a recipe for individuals placing themselves above democratic law, and some note that his defense of John Brown sits uneasily with the nonviolent reading of his work. Others regard his two years at Walden as less self-sufficient than his book suggests. Little noticed in his lifetime, he became one of the most widely read American writers.

In their words

Under a government which imprisons any unjustly, the true place for a just man is also a prison.
Resistance to Civil Government (Civil Disobedience), 1849
I think that we should be men first, and subjects afterward.
Resistance to Civil Government (Civil Disobedience), 1849

★ 12 Axes Political Test ★

How close are you to Henry David Thoreau?

Answer plain statements on 12 axes and see your match with Henry David Thoreau and every other profile on the site, axis by axis.

FAQ

Henry David Thoreau: questions

Was Thoreau an anarchist?

He is often claimed by anarchists, but in Civil Disobedience he distanced himself from the no-government men and asked for a better government rather than none at once.

Why did Thoreau go to jail?

He spent one night in jail in 1846 for refusing to pay his poll tax, in protest against slavery and the Mexican-American War. Someone else paid the tax and he was released.

What is Civil Disobedience about?

The 1849 essay argues that individuals should not let governments override their consciences and should refuse to cooperate with injustice, even at the cost of prison.