Benazir Bhutto

11th and 13th Prime Minister of Pakistan (1988-1990, 1993-1996) · Chairperson of the Pakistan Peoples Party · Leader of the Opposition · President of the Oxford Union

Pakistan Peoples Party leader and one of the first women elected to lead a Muslim-majority country, twice prime minister and twice dismissed, who was assassinated while campaigning in 2007.

Position
Solid, past the ring: second pole
Short, inside the ring: first pole
Balanced

★ Benazir Bhutto on 12 axes

Share of each pole

Economy

Equality / Markets

OwnershipMild: Private
45%55%
PublicPrivate
MarketsMild: Free
40%60%
PlannedFree
WelfareMild: Shared
60%40%
SharedSelf-reliant

State and liberty

Liberty / Authority

AuthorityMild: Democratic
65%35%
DemocraticStrong leader
SecurityModerate: Order
33%67%
LibertyOrder
StructureNo clear record
LocalCentral

Society

Progress / Tradition

MoralityBalanced
50%50%
ProgressiveTraditional
ReligionMild: Secular
58%42%
SecularReligious
TechnologyNo clear record
EmbraceCaution
CultureNo clear record
MulticulturalNational identity

World

Global / Nation

TradeNo clear record
GlobalProtected
Foreign policyMild: Strength
38%62%
CooperationStrength

How we placed it

Judgment calls

Positions summarize typical stances from primary sources and reference works. Where an axis is genuinely contested, the reasoning is below.

Ownership: Led a party founded on her father's socialist populism, but in her second term embraced privatisation and a liberal approach to the economy; scored just past the middle.
Authority: Campaigned for decades against military rule and won two elections, though she led a dynastic party and struck a power-sharing deal with General Musharraf in 2007; scored toward democratic checks.
Security: Her second government intensified internal security operations and put down opposition rallies, while abuses in custody remained common; scored toward order.
Morality: Projected a modernising image and backed women's advancement, but did not repeal the Hudood Ordinances and opposed legalised abortion; scored at the middle.
Foreign policy: Eased tensions with India in 1988-1989 but backed the Kashmiri cause and her government recognised the Taliban in 1996; scored mildly toward strength.

4 axes are marked as no clear record: there is no reasonable basis to place Benazir Bhutto there, so matching leaves them out.

Who was Benazir Bhutto?

Benazir Bhutto was born in Karachi in 1953, the daughter of Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, who founded the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) and became prime minister. She studied at Harvard and at Oxford, where she was president of the Oxford Union. After General Zia ul-Haq overthrew and executed her father, she spent years in prison and exile and took over the PPP. She won the 1988 election after Zia's death and served as prime minister until 1990 and again from 1993 to 1996. She was killed in a gun and bomb attack after a rally in Rawalpindi in December 2007.

Political views

Led the PPP's campaign against General Zia's military rule from prison and exile, and returned in 1986 to address huge rallies.
Source: news.bbc.co.uk
Presented herself as a modern woman leader in contrast to a male-dominated establishment, and later came to be seen as an icon for women's rights.
Source: en.wikipedia.org
Did not repeal the Hudood Ordinances introduced under Zia, disappointing liberal and women's rights groups.
Source: en.wikipedia.org
In her second term, oversaw economic privatisation and became increasingly open about supporting a liberal economic approach.
Source: en.wikipedia.org
Said her government's contacts with the Taliban were political engagement intended to moderate the movement and stabilise Afghanistan, and denied giving military aid.
Source: theguardian.com
Struggled to undo the president's discretionary power to dismiss elected governments, after surviving a no-confidence vote backed by former intelligence officers.
Source: bbc.com
Campaigned in 2007 for an end to militancy and against rigging of the coming election.
Source: theguardian.com

Legacy

Supporters regard Bhutto as a symbol of democracy and modernity in Pakistan and a pioneer for women in politics, and Western governments saw her as a liberal ally against militancy. Her murder made her a martyr to the PPP, which her widower Asif Ali Zardari and son Bilawal went on to lead. Critics point to the dismissal of both her governments for alleged corruption and incompetence, charges she said were politically motivated; a 1999 conviction was overturned after evidence emerged of political pressure on the judge. They also cite the corruption allegations against her husband, her government's recognition of the Taliban, and her 2007 deal with General Musharraf, which some saw as a betrayal of democratic forces.

Keep reading

★ Quick quizzes

Which Historical Leader Are You?12 statements

★ 12 Axes Political Test ★

How close are you to Benazir Bhutto?

Answer plain statements on 12 axes and see your match with Benazir Bhutto and every other profile on the site, axis by axis.

FAQ

Benazir Bhutto: questions

What political party was Benazir Bhutto?

She led the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP), founded by her father Zulfikar Ali Bhutto. She became its leader in exile in the 1980s and was its chairperson until her death.

Who killed Benazir Bhutto?

She was killed by a gunman and suicide bomber after a rally in Rawalpindi on 27 December 2007. Pakistani officials blamed Pakistani Taliban leader Baitullah Mehsud, who denied it, and a UN inquiry later called her death avoidable.

Was Benazir Bhutto left or right?

She led a centre-left party with socialist roots and a secular, modernising image, but in office she embraced privatisation and a more market-friendly economic policy.

Sources

Image credits

Portrait of Benazir Bhutto: Oliver Mark - Benazir Bhutto, Dubai 2006 (cropped).jpg by Unknown author, licensed CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Cropped, converted to grayscale and printed as a halftone by politicaltests.org; the halftone version is licensed CC BY-SA 4.0.

All portrait credits and licenses