PoliticalTests
Portrait of James Buchanan
1791-1868United States

Portrait: From Brady daguerreotype (Mathew Brady) (1822-1896), Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

James Buchanan

15th President of the United States (1857-1861) · U.S. Secretary of State · Minister to Britain and Russia · U.S. Senator from Pennsylvania

Fifteenth U.S. president, a Pennsylvania Democrat whose support for the Dred Scott decision and the Lecompton Constitution, and inaction as Southern states seceded, are widely judged among the worst presidential failures.

ECONOMYSTATE AND LIBERTYSOCIETYWORLDOwnershipMarketsWelfareAuthoritySecurityStructureMoralityReligionTechnologyCultureTradeForeign
  • Position
  • Solid, past the ring: second pole
  • Short, inside the ring: first pole
  • Balanced

★ James Buchanan on 12 axes

Share of each pole

Economy

Equality / Markets
  • OwnershipModerate: Private
    PublicPrivate
  • MarketsModerate: Free
    PlannedFree
  • WelfareModerate: Self-reliant
    SharedSelf-reliant

State and liberty

Liberty / Authority
  • AuthorityMild: Strong leader
    DemocraticStrong leader
  • SecurityMild: Order
    LibertyOrder
  • StructureModerate: Local
    LocalCentral

Society

Progress / Tradition
  • MoralityNo clear record
    ProgressiveTraditional
  • ReligionNo clear record
    SecularReligious
  • TechnologyNo clear record
    EmbraceCaution
  • CultureNo clear record
    MulticulturalNational identity

World

Global / Nation
  • TradeMild: Protected
    GlobalProtected
  • Foreign policyModerate: Strength
    CooperationStrength

How we placed it

Judgment calls

Positions summarize typical stances from primary sources and reference works. Where an axis is genuinely contested, the reasoning is below.

Ownership
No public ownership debate in his era; scored from his Democratic commitment to limited federal economic activity.
Markets
A Jacksonian Democrat who opposed federal intervention in the economy, including during the Panic of 1857.
Welfare
Took little federal action during the Panic of 1857; no welfare system existed in his era.
Authority
Endorsed the Lecompton Constitution although it had been backed by only a minority of Kansas whites, and pressed a Supreme Court justice to join a broad Dred Scott ruling.
Security
Sent an army expedition to Utah in 1857-1858 to install a federal governor in place of Brigham Young, then offered amnesty to settlers who accepted federal authority.
Structure
Held that secession was illegal but that the federal government had no power to coerce a state; scored toward local.
Morality
No documented position on family or social norms beyond the conventions of his era; left null.
Religion
His Utah policy concerned federal authority rather than religion as such; no documented program on religion in public life, so left null.
Technology
No documented view; 19th-century context.
Culture
No documented position on immigration in the sources used here; left null.
Trade
A Democrat who signed the protective Morrill Tariff in his last days in office, citing Pennsylvania's interests; scored near the middle.
Foreign policy
Co-author of the Ostend Manifesto under Pierce who kept pursuing the annexation of Cuba as president and spoke of the destiny of Americans to spread over the continent.

4 axes are marked as no clear record: there is no reasonable basis to place James Buchanan there, so matching leaves them out.

Who was James Buchanan?

James Buchanan (1791-1868), the son of Irish immigrants, became a lawyer in Pennsylvania and spent four decades in public life as a congressman, minister to Russia, senator, secretary of state under James K. Polk and minister to Britain under Franklin Pierce. His absence abroad during the Kansas-Nebraska controversy helped him win the Democratic nomination and the presidency in 1856. He hoped the Supreme Court's Dred Scott decision would settle the slavery question, but it and his support for a proslavery constitution in Kansas split his party. After Abraham Lincoln's election in 1860, seven Southern states seceded during Buchanan's final months in office while he maintained that he lacked the power to stop them.

Political views

  • Influenced the Supreme Court's 1857 Dred Scott ruling, which held that Congress could not bar slavery from the territories, by urging Justice Robert Grier to join a broad majority.

    Source: en.wikipedia.org
  • Endorsed the proslavery Lecompton Constitution for Kansas although it had been supported by only a minority of white Kansans.

    Source: millercenter.org
  • Sent a federal army to the Utah Territory in 1857 to install a new governor, later offering amnesty to residents who accepted federal authority.

    Source: en.wikipedia.org
  • Kept pressing to annex Cuba as president, although Republican opposition in Congress doomed the plans.

    Source: millercenter.org
  • Maintained after Lincoln's election that he lacked the power to stop secession and took no action against it.

    Source: millercenter.org
  • Signed the protective Morrill Tariff in March 1861, one of his last acts in office, because it served Pennsylvania's interests.

    Source: en.wikipedia.org

Legacy

Historians and presidential rankings consistently place Buchanan at or near the bottom, chiefly for his failure to halt the breakup of the Union and for policies that favored the South in the sectional crisis. Critics argue that his intervention in the Dred Scott case and his support for the Lecompton Constitution, which Senator Stephen Douglas condemned as a fraud, inflamed the North and divided the Democratic Party. Defenders, a minority, argue that he faced an almost impossible situation, that he acted within a narrow reading of his constitutional powers and that he avoided starting a war before Lincoln took office. His Utah expedition also drew criticism as costly and poorly planned. Buchanan himself spent his retirement defending his record.

★ 12 Axes Political Test ★

How close are you to James Buchanan?

Answer plain statements on 12 axes and see your match with James Buchanan and every other profile on the site, axis by axis.

FAQ

James Buchanan: questions

What political party was James Buchanan?

Buchanan was a Democrat. He won the 1856 election against Republican John C. Fremont and Know-Nothing Millard Fillmore.

What did James Buchanan do about secession?

He declared that secession was unconstitutional but argued that the federal government had no power to force a state to remain. He took no military action, though he refused to surrender Fort Sumter.

Why is James Buchanan ranked so low?

Historians fault his pro-Southern handling of Kansas and Dred Scott and his passivity as the Union broke apart in the winter of 1860-1861.